Ilyas Saliba
  • Vita
  • Research
    • Publications
    • Projects
  • Consulting
  • Communication
  • Writing
  • Photos
  • Teaching
  • Impressum

ECPR Grad Conference in Innsbruck

7/24/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
the beautiful campus @ Univeristy of Innsbruck during the BBQ with grad students lining up for free food

In July I presented a paper at the ECPR Graduate Conference in Innsbruck on the Ethnic dimension of cooptation in executives across authoritarian regimes and the impact of inclusion and exclusion on regime survival. I am writing the paper with a colleague from my Almer Mater the CIS at the ETH Zürich.

The panel was titled: "Cultural diversity as a hindering or supporting factor for regime change and stability" unfortunately the two other papers presented in this panel were not really focussing on authoritarian or regime stability but simply on case studies of ethnically heterogenious countries and the degree to which this heterogeneity has been accounted for in the politics of those countries. Or in how far there has been a pattern of inclusion or exclusion over recent decades. Therefore our paper was the only one with a particular focus on an impact of inclusion or exclusion along ethnic lines on regime stability. Nevertheless we received constructive feedback from the conveners and other participants of the panel.

In general the ECPR Graduate conference is a good way for getting a feeling of how bigger political science conferences work and to get first experiences in presenting your own work, discussing and commenting papers or chairing panels. To be honest the overall quality of the panels I visitied was rather moderate. I could not gain as much from most of the presented papers. This might also just be my subjective experience at the Graduate Conference thoug. If you have already been to conferences or presented your work in workshops or collouquia I think the best way to get forward as a PhD student is to present at conferences were actually also other -more senior- people besides your peer PhD students are presenting, discussing and listening.

This is not to say that I have not met nice and interesting people in Innsbruck but lets just say the networking possibilities and learning opportunities are obviously a bit limited due to the fact that all other particiants are also just in their PhD or even still graduate students in their Masters. 
The organization of the event was great and ECPR did a good job. In addition the venue at the University of Innsbruck was simply amazing.

Picture
the title of the paper my collegue and me presented at the conference

Besides the already mentioned conference panels and organization Innsbruck had a lot to offer aside of the conference too. Located right in between the mountains of the Alps and on the side of a river steming from the glaciers above, the city offers some extraordinary nature escapes in walking distance from tehbusy and touristy old town. The picture below was taken on a 1/2 day hike into the Sihl-valley. Getting out of the busy conference venue and exploring some of teh sorrounding nature was a real treat. 

Picture
besides the conference and the picturesque od town Innsbruck also has other things to offer. I took this foto during a short hike along the Sihl river.
0 Comments

ECPR Joint Sessions 2014 in Salamanca

4/17/2014

1 Comment

 
Picture
Jean Blondel giving the reception speech in the old building of the university
Picture

“Researching legitimacy only makes sense if investigated in combination with power or authority”[1]

During April 10th-15th the 2014 ECPR[2] joint Sessions were held in Salamanca, Spain. Host of the Sessions was the University of Salamanca, one of the oldest Universities in the world (established 1218).

I was happy to present my paper: The Impact of Authoritarian Learning on Reforms & the Legitimacy of Contested Regimes at the session on Regime Legitimisation Through Institutional Reform: Analysing its Dimensions and Effectiveness organized by Magnus Feldmann (University of Bristol) and Honarata Mazepus (University of Leiden).

The two convenors selected 20 papers from participants representing universities all across Europe and even as far as Australia. The topics were as manifold as the approaches to the rather broad topic. The overarching aim was to account for the recent re-emergence of legitimacy as a subject of investigation within political science. Reflecting upon the literature common approaches were mapped and categorized. The distinction between normative and empirical assessments of legitimacy and legitimation was the central outcome. Most participants agreed that normative approaches remain important signal posts but do barely wield advantages for assessing legitimacy and legitimation processes in the ‘real word’ due to their subjectivity. We agreed on a need to develop further the empirical approaches to legitimacy with regards to their underlying concepts and operationalization for empirical assessment.

Fundamental typologies of legitimacy and legitimation from Weber, Easton and Schumpeter were intensively discussed in the workshop. Furthermore most of the participants agreed that a focus on the processes of legitimation promises a more fruitful angle to the issue than studying levels of legitimacy at a certain moment in time. A number of papers focussed on legitimation processes in non-democracies –primarily through case studies- whereas others focussed on comparative perspective on legitimacy across the range of rather established OECD democracies.

The format of the Joint Sessions offer truly a great possibility to discuss papers and ideas under a common theme with peers from all over Europe that are working in this field. The fixed workshop belonging generates an intense working atmosphere in which scholars get to know each other and can develop thought together over the course of the 5 days. Despite differences in terms of the positions of the participants the discourse in the workshop was largely ‘Herrschaftsfrei’. Which means that there was no difference being made between me (as a first year PhD student) and distinct Professors amongst the participants.

The collegial atmosphere of the workshop contributed to getting to know each other and enjoying Spanish tapas together after the hard work was done.


All in all I can only recommend the ECP Joint Sessions as a place of scientific deliberation and debate of ones research and ideas. The comprised and intense form of working together across all hierarchical structures is a great chance to receive feedback and comments to your own work, to get a grasp of what scholars within one’s topic of interest are doing, to discuss current state of the art approaches and concepts and finally to get to know other scholars in your field.


[1] Quote form the opening presentation of the convenors
[2] European Consortium for Political Science Research

1 Comment

    RSS Feed

    Ilyas Saliba

    is a researcher and PhD student in political science, freelance journalist and photographer interested in Democracy, Transition, Authoritarianism and Security especially in the MIddle East and North Africa.

    From time to time I will publish links, comments and thoughts relating to my research, events, current political issues and the life as a PhD student on this Blog.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013

    Categories

    All
    Academia
    Arab Uprising
    Authoritarianism
    Authoritarian Learning
    Basic Rights
    Bbaw
    Berlin
    Boarders
    Brazil
    Call For Applications
    Case Studies
    Conference
    Constitution
    Cooperation
    Css
    Daad
    Democracy
    Democratization
    Diffusion
    Direct Democracy
    DVPW
    Ecpr
    Elections
    Eth
    EUI
    Europe From A Different View
    Europe In The World
    Events
    Fes
    Fieldwork
    Florence
    Free University Berlin
    GIGA
    Graduation
    Hamburg
    Hertie Foundation
    IDCAR
    IPSA
    Italy
    Ivorytower
    Jebali
    Joint Sessions
    Lecture
    Legitimacy
    Mediterranean
    Merkel
    MESA
    Methods
    Middle East
    Morocco
    Motivation
    Network
    Norway
    Nzz
    Oslo
    Phdlife
    Positions
    Publication
    Public Sphere
    Qualitative
    Reform
    Revolution
    Robert Schumann Center
    Salamanca
    Sao Paolo
    Security
    Summer School
    Switzerland
    Syria
    Transition
    Tunisia
    Visiting
    Wiko
    Workshop
    WZB


    BLOGOSPHERE

    WZB Democracy & Democratization Blog
    IR Blog
    Demokratie Blog Göttingen
    Hertie Blog
    Monkey Cage
    Adopt a Revolution


contact