Ilyas Saliba
  • Vita
  • Research
    • Publications
    • Projects
  • Consulting
  • Communication
  • Writing
  • Photos
  • Teaching
  • Impressum

Direct Democracy in Germany

12/3/2013

0 Comments

 
On the 21st of november I visited an event of the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES) in cooperation  with the Neue Zürcher Zeitung (NZZ) with the title:

Bürgergesellschaft oder Zweiklassendemokratie - wem nützt die direkte Demokratie?
Civil society or two-class democracy- who gains from direct democracy?

A sceptical input keynote from Wolfgang Merkel as made to burst of a rather one sided debate on the podium afterwards. Merkels main argument was as follows: direct democratic decision making institutions (referenda and the like) are only voted on by a minority of the people eligiblie to vote. Actually less voters turn to teh ballot box for referenda than in generel national elections. Furthermore those people that do show up to issue their voice on a particular decision do tend to be the more well off in society. The segregation between rich and poor, educated and uneducated is even stronger than it is in representative elections. 

No doubt that the overly sceptic picture Wolfgang Merkel drew in his keynote do to some extend not diminish all positive effects that are entailed in direct democratic processes but nevertheless Mr Merkel pointed top some important shortcomings of direct democratic practioces from a theoretical perspective.

Unfortunately the debate on the podium was very one sided and all five participants -including the moderater from the NZZ which seemed to have forgiotten abour siwss neutrality- were shooting against Merkels arguments. To be fair some of the points were reasonable, others empirically flawed because relying upon `special` cases and yet again others totally missed the point of Merkels critique. Mr Merkel was given the opportunity to respond to those criticisms briefly from his place in the crowd. I found the fact that the podium was building such a united front against Mr Merkel and the members of the podium badly selected and even more badly moderated.

Another scientific expert would have guaranted at least some level of empirical substiantial coiritique and at least one nother ciritique of direct democracy would have sparked a much lifelier debate.  Furthermore the fact that the moderator took sides from the beginning against the keynote speaker was simply unprofessional as a moderator that is usually expected to take a neutral stands especially if all other podium guests shoot against the keynote speaker anyway.

Some articles in the run up to the events have been published in newpspapers and are also available online:

Tagesspiegel
NZZ
Zeit
0 Comments

    RSS Feed

    Ilyas Saliba

    is a researcher and PhD student in political science, freelance journalist and photographer interested in Democracy, Transition, Authoritarianism and Security especially in the MIddle East and North Africa.

    From time to time I will publish links, comments and thoughts relating to my research, events, current political issues and the life as a PhD student on this Blog.

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013

    Categories

    All
    Academia
    Arab Uprising
    Authoritarianism
    Authoritarian Learning
    Basic Rights
    Bbaw
    Berlin
    Boarders
    Brazil
    Call For Applications
    Case Studies
    Conference
    Constitution
    Cooperation
    Css
    Daad
    Democracy
    Democratization
    Diffusion
    Direct Democracy
    DVPW
    Ecpr
    Elections
    Eth
    EUI
    Europe From A Different View
    Europe In The World
    Events
    Fes
    Fieldwork
    Florence
    Free University Berlin
    GIGA
    Graduation
    Hamburg
    Hertie Foundation
    IDCAR
    IPSA
    Italy
    Ivorytower
    Jebali
    Joint Sessions
    Lecture
    Legitimacy
    Mediterranean
    Merkel
    MESA
    Methods
    Middle East
    Morocco
    Motivation
    Network
    Norway
    Nzz
    Oslo
    Phdlife
    Positions
    Publication
    Public Sphere
    Qualitative
    Reform
    Revolution
    Robert Schumann Center
    Salamanca
    Sao Paolo
    Security
    Summer School
    Switzerland
    Syria
    Transition
    Tunisia
    Visiting
    Wiko
    Workshop
    WZB


    BLOGOSPHERE

    WZB Democracy & Democratization Blog
    IR Blog
    Demokratie Blog Göttingen
    Hertie Blog
    Monkey Cage
    Adopt a Revolution


contact